Curious, how do YOU get baby's father involved in name discussion?

Ok, here’s me: “What about this name honey?” Him: “No, its too this…”
Me: “Well then, what do you think of…?” Him: “No, it’s too that.”
Me: “Alright. No problem. Then dear, what names do YOU like?”
Him: "I dunno. …But not those (or insert name you hate).

Anyone familiar with this? It’s not that he isn’t excited about the baby, rather he just doesn’t seem to feel the same urgency to discuss names or the importance of their permanence as I do. It’s fine if he doesn’t like any of my suggestions, I can respect there’s two sides to this, but him not coming up with any of his own suggestions, or more of them is what I struggle with. Berries, how do you get your significant other to open up and get involved on this topic? I am someone who likes to have these things figured out well beore baby’s arrival so I can be confidant in our decision. What have been your experiences and how have you handled them? Thanks!

Sorry, I can’t help you much. :frowning: I don’t have a significant other, and when I talk about names with my family, if I say, for example, “I like [name]Grace[/name], for Grandma.” Then my mom will gush about how adorable that is I want to honor her mom, my grandma will get this adorable big grin on her face, my sister will complain about how she hates [name]Grace[/name] (she still hasn’t told me why, lol), and my mom will offer up another name she likes (tonight it was [name]Seth[/name], haha). When we talk about names, somehow it just comes out what names we all like. I guess my family has always pretty much liked names, with the exception of my dad. My brother’s not really into it, but he never ceases to make the conversation amusing:

“I’m going to name my son [name]Jack[/name] [name]Bauer[/name] [name]Rich[/name]@rds!” And then: “My daughter will be Shaquandanisha-[name]Latoya[/name]!” bahaha.

[name]Even[/name] when I discuss names with friends and coworkers, when I offer up names I like, they’ll always discuss what they really like, too. I have no clue what I’d do if my future husband never offered up ideas, I think it would freak me out, lol. Either that or I’d tell him, “[name]Babe[/name], if you don’t come up with some ideas, our baby will be [name]Isabelle[/name] [name]Aurora[/name] [name]Grace[/name] or [name]Caleb[/name] [name]Elias[/name] [name]Joseph[/name]. [name]Kay[/name], thanks.” :slight_smile:

Good luck!

Threaten to go with Humperdinck or [name]Bertha[/name]-[name]Kitty[/name].

Haha. My husband just says “You pick.” So then I say I’ll pick a name he hates ([name]Saskia[/name] is one) and then he’ll look over a list with me, but he doesn’t like any. So far he’s suggested three names total (in over a year) [name]Dante[/name], Viper and [name]Sophie[/name]. (Viper, seriously.) In the end, I’ll probably pick regardless.

I think the situation you’re describing is actually the norm. With most couple I know, the naming process was the mother suggesting names and the father having veto power. My husband has randomly suggested names every now and then (and this is over a three year period, mind you) but for the most part it’s me suggesting them and him either saying “yea” or “nay”.

I went through this with our last baby. My husband gets name overload very fast and I’m…a berry! Me shooting names at him every turn wasn’t good for anyone. It would give him a headache (He’s a "Why can’t we just go with the first name we both kind of like? kind of guy) and I felt like he was foo-fooing one of my favorite hobbies.

We set up some rules to get us through the process:

  1. No talking about baby names before we are pregnant.

  2. No talking about baby names until you know the Gender.

  3. If he doesn’t like any of my names, that means that he has to come up with some himself. Tell him he has to give you at least 10 and then give him time and some space from name stuff. If he won’t do this, just tell him that the baby will have a lovely name and that if he wants to like the name too, he needs to contribute (not just veto).

Sounds familiar!!

I don’t know if my hubby has ever suggested a single name! I would make a list, and then we’d go through it together for him to eliminate, or critique. I don’t really feel like I’ve picked out our girls names on my own, even though I’m the one that made the suggestions, we still talked about the names, and decided how we felt about them together.

Something that I suggested to a friend may work for you, if you can get him to make a little time for it…Give him a good baby name book (I love [name]Pam[/name] and [name]Linda[/name]'s [name]Baby[/name] Name Bible), and a pen and note pad. Tell him to go through the book and write the names he likes, and you do the same. Then compare lists to look for common names, and go from there!

When I was pregnant with my daughter more than three years ago DH and I had a similar problem–he only suggested names he thought were funny, not serious. Anyway, I went searching on Nameberry for a solution and came up with this: First, you make up a list of ten names (without his input). That is the list of names. If he wants to eliminate one of them from the list then he has to come up with one to replace it that you both agree is better than the one he wants to veto.

It totally worked for us–it really got my DH thinking about my taste in names and why I like certain names, because he had a lot of incentive to come up with ones I’d like! After he was forced to think about it more seriously I think he did end up seeing that it can be fun. Now he will even participate in an occasional discussion about hypothetical twin names, and once in a while he even reads Nameberry with me.

(Of course, it only works if you’re willing to be nice about it, too–you can’t use this method as an excuse to veto all of his names and not let him put any on the list. But it doesn’t seem like that’s what you’d try to do.)

Make up a list you love, leave it till the last week befor you show him the list and then give him an option to choose one of the names, otherwise choose the one you like the most. He is too busy with work etc and it doesn’t seem like a big deal.

rollo

On [name]Grey[/name]'s Anatomy, one of the characters was pregnant with her male friend’s baby, and she and her spouse and he were arguing over names. She finally said “We each get a vote, but I’m the one who [detailed description of natural birth process], so my va-jay-jay also gets a vote. And we like _____.” Or something to that effect; I’m not exactly sure how it went, but that’s close. I loved it and decided that when the time comes, I’m going to claim some of those extra votes!

Actually I will probably just talk to him about how much certain names mean to me and that kind of thing.

Sorry for the long post, I’m a rambler when my son is sleeping. :slight_smile:

My sister had the same problem. She has a very Top-10 naming style, so nothing she was suggesting was “out there” in ANY way. He also had the same style, but for some reason was vetoing Everything she suggested and wasn’t being helpful in the least (though he was a bit of an ____, and is now an ex-husband, so he could have just wanted to be difficult). Anyway…she finally got to a point and just told him that she was the one they would had the birth certificate to and she was going to write down whatever she wanted and he could like it or not. After that, he “helped” her decide on [name]Jessica[/name], which was her favorite pick all along.

Our first born’s mn was harder to do than any other name! He decided on it after a [name]LONG[/name] time of me going over countless names and giving him many emailed lists. I think he wasn’t taking the mn with as much consideration/urgency as the fn. We finally got to [name]Alexander[/name] toward the end of the pregnancy by giving him a list of my top 10 middle names and just telling him that he had to pick one from it, since he wasn’t offering up any suggestions of his own and didn’t seem to like any of the ones I was throwing at him individually.

But, in general, I have been Very lucky with my Husband. He actually was the one who picked [name]Conor[/name] as our first’s fn. He was deciding between [name]Conor[/name] and [name]Liam[/name]. I really wanted him to be involved as much as possible and I Really liked both names, so I didn’t bother offering any other suggestions. I felt like it would help create a bond for him from the beginning that I didn’t have to worry about because of my obvious already insanely close bond. The only way I would have been forceful about any name was if he ended up picking [name]Liam[/name], I would have insisted that the middle name in some way was after my father, since He and his dad both have the [name]William[/name]/[name]Liam[/name] connection.

For our twins…before we found out it was twins. I suggested [name]Cormac[/name] for a boy or [name]Cordelia[/name] for a girl. He was 100% on [name]Cordelia[/name] from the beginning. He wasn’t so sure about [name]Cormac[/name], but didn’t veto it. It was too early for him to think/care about it too much. And, by the time I got past the big miscarriage-risk mark and really started about names, he had met a [name]Cormac[/name] [name]IRL[/name]. And slowly after the name had time to settle in his mind, he couldn’t think of a little boy as anything other than [name]Cormac[/name]. After we found out twins, we decided to go ahead and use [name]Cormac[/name] and [name]Cordelia[/name] for both of their names, even though they were more matchy than I would have liked for twins. He also picked their middle names, out of nowhere, as we were getting into bed one night. He just said, “What about [name]Cormac[/name] [name]Sebastian[/name] & [name]Cordelia[/name] [name]Jane[/name]?” I thought they were Perfect, so that was that (other than pointing out he picked [name]Jane[/name] not thinking that it was my mother’s mn, and me wanting to add [name]Marie[/name] to it in some fashion for his mother also…so eventually Janemarie came about).

I think that some men just need the wake-up call of being a little forceful about it and telling them that you need him to participate in a way that you consider to be better/more helpful, or you’re going to pick whatever you want to. And then tell him exactly [name]How[/name] you need him to be more helpful. Hints don’t seem to work, the more straight forward the better.

Let him know that it’s Really important to you, and whether or not he can Understand that, you want him to be Supportive of how you feel and work with you. Point out that it’s a Good thing that you want him to be involved. That you could be one of those women who just pick what they like and are rigid about it, not caring about the father’s opinion.

And with my husband it always helps, for a number of different situations, if I “jokingly” point out how stereo-typically “male” his actions are. He subconsciously starts trying to act in a way to prove me wrong and ends up doing what I wanted him to in the first place! :stuck_out_tongue_winking_eye:

Ooohh, I also wanted to mention what worked for a close friend, since different people respond to different things.

She had to point out to him how he would feel in a similar type of situation. At the time he was Very into planning a house for them. He had always wanted to build his own house and she used that to help him understand. She asked him how frustrated he would feel if every time he brought her a different plan, she just said “no”. If she wouldn’t tell him exactly why she didn’t like it, to the best of her ability. And, if she offered no other suggestion as to what she would like better. If plan, after plan, she just said “nope”. Then he understood her reasoning.

Though you have to make him think in terms of him really Wanting your opinion and to make you happy as well in the choice. If cars are his thing, you have to stress that he really wants to choose a new one that makes the [name]Both[/name] of you happy.

You could have a few options with that tactic. Houses, cars, him trying to plan the “perfect” vacation, a garden layout, money investments. Really depends on if he’s into anything that you can use as an example.

I would agree with the quoted above. My husband and I have been together for 9 years (married over 6) and in that time he has only offered up 2 names on his own… but vetoed a bunch of mine. What really turned the tides was me writing a baby blog journaling our infertility, and expressing myself thoroughly through a media source that naming was a passion of mine and was one of the bright spots in this long battle of ours. I then started a baby name of the month on my blog and explained in detail what I loved about each name. He began reading these posts and it opened up a whole world of discussion. He still has not yet offered any more than 2 serious names, but does have much longer and meaningful discussions about names we can both agree on from my list. We now have named future children… just need to work on this pregnancy/adoption thing.

You are pregnant so of course doing a baby name of the month would be difficult since you have a much shorter time… but maybe doing a baby name every other day on a personal blog or journal and letting him read it would open up the lines of communication. To write down your feelings of urgency and preparedness also might help and let him read it rather than you two being frustrated in the car at your name suggesting and his vetoing everything.

Good luck!.

Here is my little blog in case it helps http://suchstuffasdreamsaremadeonblog.blogspot.com/

My husband hates talking about baby names. With our first pregnancy, I had a list of about twenty girl names and twenty boy names that I liked. One or two of the names on the list may have been his suggestions. I printed out two copies of the names (one for each of us) and we went out to eat one night. We both sat and ate and looked over the lists. We crossed off names that we wouldn’t choose for a first name. The rule was that if either of us crossed off a name, that was it. It was no longer in consideration. After ten or fifteen minutes, I took both lists, and wrote down the names that neither of us had crossed off. Then we both took that list (again, one for each of us) and ranked them. Then I compared our rankings, and that’s how we ended up with Lucia! (I think Lucia was his #1 choice and Lucia was my #2 of the names that were left).

Of course, this was all so taxing that DH didn’t have it in him to go through the middle names in the same fashion, so after Lucia was born I basically chose her middle name since he doesn’'t much care about middles. We did basically the same procedure during our second pregnancy.

Honestly, this whole choosing a baby name thing has been much less enjoyable than I imagined it would be.

My parents both wrote a list of names they liked and my name was on both of them so that was simple-But they aren’t name nerds like I am so I don’t think it mattered that much. I don’t think my husband is getting much say in it! Maybe I’ll give him a list of combos I like and let him choose-but it will be hard!

I actually got him to write a list! He’s working on it a lot, I sneaked a peek the other day and there’s a lot of weird names there… slightly terrifying! So we’re going to look at each others lists and mark our likes and dislikes and hopefully something good will come out of it… Most of the men I know really wants to be involved in the process, but most find it absurd to choose a name until they see the baby. Men are very visual.