HELP! Sedona or Sidonie?! opinions needed

[name]Hi[/name] everyone! I just wanted your thoughts and opinions on something,
Living in the US do you like [name]Sedona[/name] or the french [name]Sidonie[/name] better? how do each of the names sound to you and do you feel that they each send off different vibes or different images?
Also how would [name]Sidonie[/name] be pronounced in the US? like [name]Si[/name]-[name]DO[/name]-knee or [name]SI[/name]-[name]DO[/name]-nee or would you almost skip over the O and say it fast so that it almost sounds like sydney? or maybe even [name]Sid[/name]-uh-nee??

Thanks!

I don’t really like [name]Sedona[/name] at all, but I’m not a fan of place names.

[name]Sidonie[/name], even though it is legit, looks like a trendy spelling of [name]Sydney[/name] and I think it will be pronounced the same as well.

I [name]Love[/name] [name]Sidonie[/name]. I do worry a bit though about people hearing it and thinking it it’s [name]Sydney[/name]. I would say it [name]Si[/name]-do-nee.

I don’t care for [name]Sedona[/name] at all, it feels a little cheap, [name]IMO[/name].

[name]Sidonie[/name], on the other hand, is beautiful! I say it “sid-on-ee”, so a [name]LITTLE[/name] like [name]Sidney[/name], but the -on is a distinct sound. I love it. You could also do [name]Sidonia[/name], kind of the best of both names.

I know a little girl named [name]Sidonie[/name] and I absolutely love her name!

Honestly, I think most people would pronounce [name]Sidonie[/name] as [name]Sidney[/name], assuming it is a stab at trendy spelling. If that is going to bother you, you might want to stay away from that one.

[name]Sedona[/name] is the name of a makeup brush company ([name]Sedona[/name] [name]Lace[/name]).

[name]Sedona[/name] sounds pretty, but reminds me too much the [name]Kia[/name] vehicle.

[name]Sidonie[/name] (I would pronounce it see-DOH-nee) I don’t like at all. It sounds awkward to me and not pretty at all. There are so many lovely french names, but this one isn’t appealing to me.

These were my thoughts as well.

I went to college with a [name]Sidonie[/name] nn [name]Sid[/name]. I always loved her name. She pronounced it [name]Si[/name]-doh-nee. The way she pronounced it doesn’t really remind me of [name]Sydney[/name] at all, but I am sure she was confused as [name]Sydney[/name] every once and awhile. I much prefer [name]Sidonie[/name] to [name]Sedona[/name].

My daughter is a [name]Sidonie[/name]! The correct aka French pronunciation is SEE-dough-KNEE (with two accents, the first and third). It sounds super awkward to me when people say “[name]Si[/name]” instead of of “See”. Her nn is Sido by the way (just like [name]Colette[/name]'s mum!)

[name]Sidonie[/name] with the pronunciation nowx3 described.

If you like this sort of sound, have you considered Cedonia (sĕh-d”n-ya)? Similar to [name]Sedona[/name], but to me it sounds a bit nicer, and it doesn’t have the [name]Kia[/name] association.