Well, my name is Jennifer, so let’s start there.
I’m a long time fan of Linda and Pam and have a first edition of Beyond Jennifer and Jason: The Enlightened Guide to Naming Your Baby. I picked it up over twenty years ago when I was a young teenager…somewhere around the age of 12 or 13 I think. I loved it because I am one of many Jennifers, and at the time, I wished my name was anything but Jennifer!
That being said, I’m now pushing 40, and I LOVE my name. There’s a reason it was a number one name for twenty years. There’s a reason it didn’t fall out of the top fifty until 2006. There’s a reason it will come back one day and be popular again. It’s a freaking awesome name. I’ve said it here on different threads quite a few times. It’s got all the qualities of a perfect Nameberry name, aside from its recent popularity. It’s got a rich and lovely history dating back to the Welsh Gwenfrewi and Cornish Guinevere. It’s also got an interesting sound and combination of consonant sounds…J/F/R…it’s not like any other name (and no, I’m not counting “Juniper” because Juniper has a much harder sound than Jennifer–say them both aloud and listen to the difference).
I hate that so many people just trash my name because it was super popular. As someone who has worn a popular name, I will say I tend to gravitate towards less popular names, BUT some of my favorite names are very popular and/or common ones: Hailey, Ava, Isabelle, Sophie, Sarah, Olivia, Emily, Paige, Valerie, and Kaylee (this spelling because Browncoat FOREVER), for example. I don’t hate the names because they are popular, and I don’t bash parents who choose them. Popularity doesn’t ruin a name for me, even though it makes me less likely to use it, no matter how much I like it, mainly because I already know a lot of people who HAVE used it, and I don’t want to copy them.
However, even though I LOVE some really out there names, I’m also hesitant about using some of them as well, just because I want my children to really like their names, too, and not feel like I was just indulging my own interests at their expense. I tend to love names attached to characters I love, but some of them (Neytiri, Rukia, and Galadriel, for example) just aren’t usable for real, actual people. (I remember an episode of Night Court where Mac and Quon Le had their baby and she told him she wanted to name their daughter after her favorite character from her favorite book, and he immediately agreed…the name? FLICKA. As in the horse. And while some Berries think the nn Flick is just super-cute, all it makes ME think about is flicking boogers, as in, “pick it, flick it, watch it stick.” And of course, the horse. They ended up using Flicka as a mn, but still, that episode made a huge impression on me as a child!)
That being said, I do have a problem with “kreatif” names because I don’t think changing the spelling enhances a name that much, and sometimes it just makes it look silly. I saw an “Analyse” that was supposed to be pronounced “Anna-leese” but just looked like the British version of “analyze.” Some names have acceptable variants: C/Katherine, Eliz/sabeth, C/Kaitlin, Haley/Hailey, for example. Sometimes, though, though, parents can take even this too far and end up with the Kardashian effect and the names end up looking dated. Also, sometimes changing letters can confuse pronunciations, as in, G/J or even C/K, so I think parents should be careful there, too.
I really do wonder why some parents feel the need to change the spelling of names so much, too. Changing the spelling doesn’t make it a different or more unique name, so aside from sheer aesthetics, why? (Note: I am fine with two versions of most names, at the most three, if considering minor differences like endings of -y/-ie/or even -eigh, but after that, it can get ridiculous. And some names, like Jennifer, shouldn’t ever be changed…I’m looking at you, Ginnifer Goodwin–born Jennifer Goodwin!)
Edit to add: Most of the time, I don’t dislike names so much as I dislike the associations I have with them via other people or characters. If I have strong feelings about those associations, it’s worse. For example, Dolores, for me, will ALWAYS be the evil, hateful Dolores Umbridge from Harry Potter, and Thatcher will always be Meredith’s disgustingly weak and pitiful excuse for a father on Grey’s Anatomy. My brain is like Velcro for pop-culture references, and sometimes I point those out when I post here, especially if I have a particularly negative association with the name because of that. I think every parent should be informed of loathsome associations…especially of more uncommon names. Names like Tom (as in Tom Riddle, a.k.a Lord Voldemort from Harry Potter), however, can stand up to those associations because there are more Toms around and a child won’t necessarily be ostracized for having a bad name association.
Also, I think NB has helped sway me on a few names. Dorothy, for example. I used to hate it, but now I like it…not enough to use for my own child, but I would admire it on someone else’s child. There are very few names that I don’t like just based on the name itself, and that’s usually because of the way it sounds OR because it’s a name that I think of just being there because Baby had to have a name.
I have requested opinions on names before and don’t always get a positive response…for example, when I first heard the name Tosca, it was when I met writer Tosca Lee, and I liked the name, but wasn’t sure if I was more impressed with it or with her (because she’s really cool and she’s a great writer and she had the most amazing pair of boots I have ever seen!). I got a really negative response to the name on the forums, but realized that I didn’t really care, which told me that I needed to add it to my list. A few years later, and I still love it!