You have such a lovely list, and I adore all the spunky nicknames! Ranked in order of preference:
- Alberta “Birdie” – absolutely loving Alberta “Birdie”! She’s so spunky & has a lovely vintage charm that is just so underrated. I think Alby / Albie would make a lovely nickname options as well!
- Marigold “Goldie”
- Edith “Edie”
- Theda “Teddy” – Theda is so stunning & underused! Teddy is adorable as well!
- Jordana “Georgie” – love Jordana & Georgie! Though I also wanted to suggest Jory or Jordy as nicknames as well!
- Francesca “Frankie”
- Valerie “Valley”
- Maxine “Max”
- Winifred “Freddie”
- Scotia “Scottie” – I don’t mind Scottie, I just don’t love Scotia as a first name as it does feel very tied to the Canadian Province. For Scottie, I would probably opt for Scarlett or just Scottie as a standalone