To rename or not to rename...

…[name]Caroline[/name] and [name]Henrietta[/name]. Or [name]Mercy[/name] and [name]Franklin[/name]. See, they’re all in one family, and their names have been bugging me for a while. [name]Mercy[/name] and [name]Franklin[/name] sound American colonial, while [name]Caroline[/name] and [name]Henrietta[/name] sound more British colonial. [name]Caroline[/name] is sickly, something I never attributed to that name, and [name]Henrietta[/name] is peppy, something I never attributed to that name either. [name]Mercy[/name] and [name]Franklin[/name] are great personality wise, but they seem to stick out. I’ve already gotten a ways with this story, and I don’t know if changing the name would screw me up. So…stuck in a pickle. Help?

Background: This is a working class family in an east American quarry in 1878.

Family as I have it:
Father: Wincor Macston (wanted a variation of [name]Cormac[/name], might change back to [name]Cormac[/name]?)
Mother: [name]Juliet[/name] Macston (this one I like)
Kids:
[name]Jonathon[/name] - would be 16. Died when he was 14 in a mining accident. This was two years ago. (this one I also like)
[name]Caroline[/name] - 8. Very quiet and sickly. Likes sewing.
[name]Henrietta[/name] - 8, twin of the above. Very energetic and exuberant. Like little kids.
[name]Mercy[/name] - 4. [name]Just[/name] your average four year old minor character. Loves her family and playing.
[name]Franklin[/name] - 2. Again, just your average two year old minor character. Fun-loving toddler.

Thanks in advance!

While names are a significant part of the character, what’s more important is that you’ve created a solid, believable, and relatable conception that has a purpose in the story and can help move the plot forward. If you’re confident you’ve done that, then do a search & change modification to your word processor and keep on writing. See how you like the new names. If you don’t like them, change them back. Nothing’s final until it’s published.

Thanks for the advice. :slight_smile: I think I’ll keep the names the way they are for now. I’m starting to see their character, like you said.