I said meaning was important but I think honoring someone is important too. And the general flow of the name with the last name. Those are the three most important criteria for me.
I put masculinity because…well, I’m honestly pretty big on there being “boy names” and “girl names”. So when I choose a name for a son, I want it to definitely say “I’m a boy”. Then I’d have to say handsome, followed by unpopular, although I try not to get too held up on popularity to an extent. The other things don’t really matter to me.