From most to least popular among those surveyed. If you want to take any of the surveys still before I tally them, please do. 
Comments welcome.
Alastair: 36 votes
Archie: 29 votes
Alaric: 26 votes
Aurelio: 23 votes
Abner : 21 votes
Anthony: 20 votes
Adam: 19 votes
Amory: 14 votes
Aeneas: 13 votes
Alain and Albion: 9 votes each
Alonso: 7 votes
Antoine: 6 votes
Androcles: 4 votes
Agassi: 2 votes
Interesting to see that Alaric was almost as liked as the more known Alastair. It and Albion might make nice alternatives to Alastair.