I love the nickname [name]Penny[/name], for many reasons. But I just don’t think [name]Penelope[/name] is my style. Any other suggestions of full names?
I might consider just naming a child [name]Penny[/name], but I worry it would seem plain compared to siblings.
Literally every name I can think of in which [name]Penny[/name] seems to work as a nickname:
[name]Parthenope[/name]
[name]Aspen[/name]
Rupinder
Pina
Penka
[name]Persephone[/name]
[name]Penina[/name] / [name]Peninnah[/name]
Despina
[name]Giuseppina[/name]
Proserpina
Also, maybe [name]Peony[/name] would work for the similar sound while being a bit more unusual.
[name]Peniel[/name], means “face of God”
any P- first name + [name]Nicole[/name] as mn
[name]Petronella[/name]
[name]Payton[/name]/[name]Peyton[/name]
[name]Pearleen[/name]/[name]Pearlina[/name]
[name]Pauline[/name]/[name]Paulina[/name]
[name]Penrose[/name]
[name]Patience[/name]
[name]Peregrine[/name]
[name]Phoenix[/name]
[name]Prudence[/name]
I think this would be a cute nickname for a redhead of any name.
I have a friend who just named her daughter [name]Penny[/name]. [name]Just[/name] [name]Penny[/name] 
It suits her and big sis is named [name]Piper[/name]. I don’t think using [name]Penny[/name] alone is plain at all.
So far I really like the suggestions [name]Aspen[/name], [name]Penina[/name] & [name]Penrose[/name] Hmm how about…
[name]Perrine[/name]
[name]Petrina[/name]
[name]Spencer[/name]
Independence
[name]Pernella[/name]
[name]Esperanza[/name]/[name]Esperance[/name]
[name]Pearline[/name]
Perenelle
Peryn
I’ve been contemplating [name]Millicent[/name] nn [name]Penny[/name] lately. Is the cent=penny connection to silly? I’m not sure!
So creative, without being too creative. I think it is super cute!
Okay, so this might only work as a middle name but Tuppence - I have recently fallen in love with it. [name]Penny[/name] is sweet though - good luck!
I love a lot of these suggestions! You are all so smart. I particularly like [name]Aspen[/name], because I liked it already and now it has a cute nickname.
Tuppence is cute. And funny because you can get penny from the way it sounds, the -pence part. But it is also a variant spelling of twopence (correct me if I am wrong) which is equal to two pennies. Cute!
What about [name]Penn[/name] nn [name]Penny[/name]? I’m liking that one.
Oooh, I love the idea of [name]Persephone[/name]! But probably not your style if you don’t like [name]Penelope[/name].