I’m glad you wrote this post.
I don’t really have that much time right now but I wanted to add at least a little.
Vanessa is a made-up name too. It was invented by Jonathan Swift in 1726 for a poem he wrote. Now of course you could say that it was almost 300 years ago and therefor has a history now, but at one point it was Nevaeh.
I’m not American and I read in other (non-American) forums as well. I have seen this trend in all of them in different kind of ways.
I strongly believe it is a class issue, sometimes even a race issue. Nevaeh and names like that are considered lower-class. I believe that nameberry is a place with lots of people from middle and upper-class. It is a open minded place when it comes to very uncommon names. But only in one direction, in the direction that still sounds middle or upper class.
I believe on other websites you would get very different reviews for names like Nevaeh because there are different people there.
I find it interesting to read one of my preposters opinion that a Nevaeh might be born upper class but won’t stay upper class, which of course it not true. While I agree that you name is part of your first impression, it’s not what decides everything in your life.
So if your parents are rich, send you to a private school, you have good grades and you apply for a job people won’t be like “oh i see she has great grades, she seems very nice, but her name is Nevaeh, we can’t take her…”
Anyways, what I wanted to give as another example of class issues when it comes to naming is the situation in Germany (and this is only the example because that’s the other language I’m reading in, I know it exists in other countries as well). There we associate American / English names with lower class so people are strongly opposed to them. No Jayden, no Justin, no John there.
Because everyone actually believes they sound ugly? I don’t believe that. But the association and fear to be associated with something you don’t want to be is so strong that at one point you don’t even realise anymore where this “dislike” once came from.
And I think it is great that you wrote this post becasue while we don’t have to change our opinions it is good to acknowledge where they stem from. It’s about privilige that we have and want to keep.
I want to add something else:
We always say that it will be harder to get a job and all that and I do believe names can have an impact in situations like that.
But we need to be aware of that and make sure it doesn’t happen. Yes, Maysynn might come from a lower class family (she also might come from a midde or upper class family, we don’t know) but that all it tells us. Not giving her a job because you think that she might have been born into a lower class family is just wrong and discriminatory.