Mecca for a girl-honest thoughts and opinions

I have recently fallen in love with this unusual place name and think it could be a very special name for my future daughter. I have been thinking alot lately about names that have a special meaning and connect children to their heritage, ancestors, and a sense of spirituality. I am not super religious, but I am deeply spiritual and the Muslim faith of my family means alot to me. My faith has a huge impact on my identity and world view, and I would love a name that gives my child this sense of pride in their background. [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] is not a typical given name, but I love the symbolism of making the pilgrimage to the holy city.

What do you think of using [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] as a first or middle name? I would love to hear the good, bad, and ugly.

Given your heritage, I would say it’s your call to make. Have you asked any family members what they think of [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] as a given name? If I met a [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] I would assume she came from a Muslim background, and then I would think it was strange that her parents named her [name_f]Mecca[/name_f].

I knew a [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] in high school, so I don’t think it’s that strange at all–given that you’re Muslim. If you’re not (or you have no Muslim background at all), than I would be a little confused. I think it’s a nice sounding name and not dissimilar in sound to other names ([name_f]Jenna[/name_f], [name_f]Becca[/name_f], [name_f]Emma[/name_f])

If I met a girl named [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] I would think…Great name! that is a really cool name her Mom gave her—I like it!

The meaning is lovely, but I don’t find the sound of ‘[name_f]Mecca[/name_f]’ to be attractive…Medina?

Since you’re Muslim, I think it’s okay. I don’t really know how Muslims feel about [name_f]Mecca[/name_f] as a name. If they’re cool, then why not?

As long as you’re Muslim, I say go for it! I’d also suggest my own name for you, if that isn’t too obnoxious… [name_f]Janna[/name_f], as in [name_f]Heaven[/name_f], feels a lot more wearable and is also very uncommon.

It’s not too bad. If it fits you and you feel comfortable, then go with it.

Honest opinion though: my first thoughts when I clicked on this were ‘Mecha’… Like a robot person. I found it quite amusing.

Agree. Strong name but doesn’t sounds as lovely as what it means.

I think as a middle it would be lovely and meaningful!

I think she would be the butt-end of jokes throughout her [name_m]History[/name_m] classes.

I don’t find the name attractive, but the symbolism is nice.