I think Mary is one of those names that quietly comes back around and suddenly feels right again. On a baby today, Mary actually does feel fresh and a bit unexpected, especially without being a double name or nickname. It’s simple, grounded, and timeless in a way that stands out among more elaborate choices right now.
I love the idea of pairing it with something bold. Mary Edelweiss is honestly beautiful, romantic, meaningful, and definitely gives Mary that extra spark you’re looking for.
A few other ideas that feel “recognised but unexpected”:
Mary Clementine
Mary Delphine
Mary Valentine
Mary Lavender
Mary Jessamine
Mary Olympia
Mary Azalea
Mary Florence
Hope this helps!